Saturday, October 22, 2011

OWS: Ignorant Villagers with Pitchforks

U of Chicago economist Steven Kaplan updates data on income skews.



If some of the OWS crowd would actually use that tuition they want from others to pay for economics courses, they would know that income disparity ALWAYS falls during periods of economic contraction or stagnation and rises during periods of high economic growth.
The reason should be pretty obvious (unless you don’t want it to be). It is the same reason that in years of favorable weather, the crop yield widens between those who farm rich land with pesticides and mechanization and those who farm poor land with hand tools.
Since the 1980s we have been in a long-term secular expansion driven by rapid technology innovation and (relatively) favorable policies toward investment. Those with high intellectual capital and high personal motivation have been able to increase their “crop yields” much faster than those who lack those attributes.
This is not a conspiracy hatched on Wall Street. It is a simple fact of economics. If you want the amenities that economic growth brings, you WILL have greater disparities in income. The Wall Street occupiers who seek greater equality of income are like villagers praying for years of bad weather so that the farmers will be more nearly equal.

See also http://econocentric.blogspot.com/2011/08/egalitarians-rejoice-in-recession.html

Monday, October 10, 2011

The Takers Are Outnumbering the Makers

The chart below looks much like many others did  -- tech stocks in 1999, housing prices in 2006, oil prices in 2008, national debt in 2011. As with the others, it is simply not sustainable. No amount of Hope, no amount of good intentions, no postponement until after the next election is going to change that fundamental fact.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Is it Ignorance or Arrogance?

The President had a very revealing comment in his interview with George Stephanopoulos the other day. They were discussing the recent trend to banks charging customers directly for debit card usage.

PRESIDENT OBAMA: Well, you can stop it because it-- if you-- if you say to the banks, "You don't have some inherent right just to-- you know, get a certain amount of profit.

What to say about this incredible lack of understanding of economics and appreciation for American liberty?

First of all, Mr. President, at the risk of using concepts too simple for you: There is no Free Lunch. Those charges are appearing because YOU (actually Senator Durbin with your endorsement) stuck your monkey-wrench into the machinery of the market,  limiting banks' historical practice of charging customers indirectly via merchant swipe charges (if you think retailers don't pass on their costs to customers via higher prices, you are even more ignorant than I thought).

But your point that banks don't have a right to earn a profit in excess of whatever you deem worthy is simply stunning. Since when? 2008? Banks, like every other enterprise are in business to maximize the profits for their owners. There is no other purpose. They do so by structuring products that customers want to buy. If they err in those assessments, customers will exercise their right to take their business elsewhere. You might recall how this plays out in other industries. Much of the airline industry has decided to break out baggage charges from ticket costs. Some of the industry -- most prominently Southwest Airlines -- have chosen not to. Flyers decide which method they prefer. 

Customers and banks will decide which method of paying for the cost of operating accounts they prefer. I don't know what they'll decide and neither do you --except that you don't want them to decide. You want to decide for them. And apparently you want to decide what level of profit a bank has a "right" to earn, too.

Voters in 2008 voted for a change in Washington, They did not vote for a change in America. It's time to remind the White House about that again next year.

Monday, October 3, 2011

Revenge of the Free Lunch


Last week I was watching someone interview one of the Wall Street "occupiers".  This person told the interviewer that he was protesting, among other things, the fact that banks were going to “stick it to us” by charging new fees for debit card usage. Obviously this mental giant had not spent any of his college years in economics class where he might have learned:

1. There is no Free Lunch.

2. Debit card systems cost real money to operate. Banks have historically gotten this money from merchant fees every time you used a debit card. Although these fees may have been collected directly from merchants, you paid for them indirectly through the higher prices that merchants had to charge you (see learning #1) whether or not you used a debit card.

3. The new debit card charges are a direct result of Senator Durbin’s amendment to the Dodd-Frank monstrosity that severely limited debit card merchant fees. Banks simply shifted the cost of the debit card system from you indirectly to you directly (see learning #1).

If he wanted want to protest this, why was he not railing against Senator Durbin? Or is there a professional courtesy among the economically ignorant?