Saturday, January 28, 2012
Real GDP Falls Because the Rich Aren't Taxed Enough
Yesterday the "good news" from the White House was that Q4 GDP grew at a 2.8% rate. This brings GDP up to a stunning 1.5% for the year 2011. But the really important stat is that real (inflation adjusted) GDP has actually fallen by 1.2% over the last 5 years. Against a backdrop of zero growth, the biggest economic issue in the State of the Union address was . . . . growth? Nope. According to the President what's been holding us back -- the reason there has been been no growth in the economy -- is that The Rich aren't paying enough in taxes. In fact in order to get more investment capital in the economy the President proposes to double the tax on capital gains from 15% to 30%. Now there's a real growth initiative. What's next? Another tax on seed and fertilizer to get crop production going?
Friday, January 27, 2012
The Food Stamp President
Yesterday President Obama blamed (what a surprise) President Bush for the expansion in food stamp recipients. Apparently it's the well-known four year lag effect, not the increase in the amount of benefits contained in his "stimulus" bill? The President just seems to have a hard time grasping Economics 101: when you increase the subsidy of an activity, you will get more of that activity.
a
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Unfair?
President Obama seems intent on making Tax the Rich the mantra of his reelection campaign. He eschews economics for emotion in his appeal because, well, there really aren't any good economic arguments to support that position. But just for the moment let's examine the facts behind the emotions of the "fairness" issue. The President's main complaint seems to be that it's "not fair" for The Rich to be paying less of their income in taxes than the Middle Class. First of all, that's not factually correct as is readily apparent from the CBO data below (You have to assume that the President has access to this data if I can find it, so he either has a very poor memory or is just lying about it).
Beyond that, though, is this word "fairness". What exactly is unfair about the top 1% of earners paying 19% of the income in federal income tax while middle class families (presumably those in the 20th through 80th percentile of income earners) pay 4% of their income in federal income tax? Is that 4% really unfair? If so, what should it be then? Zero? Or is the President perhaps simply disingenuously mining the economic ignorance of the public? Do you really think the Middle Class should be incensed that they are "unfairly" being forced to cough up a whopping 4.2% of their income in federal income tax?
The President is not the first person to appeal to blind envy -- nor will he be the last. After all, they always teach in debate class that when you don't have a good factual argument, call people names and appeal to their prejudices.
| Average Income Tax As % | ||
| Quintile | Of Total Income | |
| Top 1% | 18.8% | |
| Rest of Top 20% | 11.8% | |
| Middle 20-80% | 4.2% | |
| Bottom Quintile | -5.6% (Negative due to tax credits) | |
Source: Congressional Budget Office
Beyond that, though, is this word "fairness". What exactly is unfair about the top 1% of earners paying 19% of the income in federal income tax while middle class families (presumably those in the 20th through 80th percentile of income earners) pay 4% of their income in federal income tax? Is that 4% really unfair? If so, what should it be then? Zero? Or is the President perhaps simply disingenuously mining the economic ignorance of the public? Do you really think the Middle Class should be incensed that they are "unfairly" being forced to cough up a whopping 4.2% of their income in federal income tax?
The President is not the first person to appeal to blind envy -- nor will he be the last. After all, they always teach in debate class that when you don't have a good factual argument, call people names and appeal to their prejudices.
Saturday, January 21, 2012
Wealth Creation is Not a Poker Game
Sometimes I think people spend too much time playing poker and not enough time thinking about economics. In a poker game whenever there is a big winner, everyone else has to be a net loser. That's the way that game works. In the real world of free-market economics, whenever there is a big winner there have to be lots of other winners. Those other winners voluntarily exchanged money with the big winners for something that they thought was more valuable than the money. Let's run down the list of some of the Big Winners of today.
Bill Gates. Are you worse off because Bill made a lot of money selling you software?
Warren Buffett. How did Berkshire Hathaway investments in companies like Kraft, Coca-Cola and American Express harm you?
Larry Ellison. Do Oracle databases detract from your standard of living?
Steve Jobs. Do wish you had never heard of iPods or iPhones or iMacs?
The Walton Family. Do millions of people go to Wal-Mart just to get raped with high prices?
Jeff Bezos. How does ordering from Amazon make you worse off?
Larry Page. Don't you just hate it when Google gives you information?
You can keep going down this list and you're not going to find many that achieved their great wealth by harming you in some way. How is it then that when you consolidate them into "The 1%", they become something evil that must be discouraged? (Other than the obvious answer -- envy). Do you really not want there to be a new Steve Jobs or Jeff Bezos or Warren Buffett? They're not playing poker with you. They are offering up goods and services that you really want. And we're all better off because of them.
Bill Gates. Are you worse off because Bill made a lot of money selling you software?
Warren Buffett. How did Berkshire Hathaway investments in companies like Kraft, Coca-Cola and American Express harm you?
Larry Ellison. Do Oracle databases detract from your standard of living?
Steve Jobs. Do wish you had never heard of iPods or iPhones or iMacs?
The Walton Family. Do millions of people go to Wal-Mart just to get raped with high prices?
Jeff Bezos. How does ordering from Amazon make you worse off?
Larry Page. Don't you just hate it when Google gives you information?
You can keep going down this list and you're not going to find many that achieved their great wealth by harming you in some way. How is it then that when you consolidate them into "The 1%", they become something evil that must be discouraged? (Other than the obvious answer -- envy). Do you really not want there to be a new Steve Jobs or Jeff Bezos or Warren Buffett? They're not playing poker with you. They are offering up goods and services that you really want. And we're all better off because of them.
Friday, January 20, 2012
The Big Lie About Taxes
Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
Various people -- from Occupiers to Warren Buffet to the President of the United States -- have served up a lie that suits them: That high income earners pay less of their income in federal taxes than "middle class" earners. The media obediently repeats the lie. Here are the facts.
| Average Tax As Percent of Income | ||
| Quintile | Income Taxes | All Federal Taxes |
| Top 1% | 18.8% | 29.5% |
| Rest of Top Quintile | 11.8% | 22.8% |
| Middle Quintiles | 4.2% | 15.1% |
| Bottom Quintile | -5.6% | 4.7% |
Source: Congressional Budget Office
You're entitled to argue that the 1% should pay even more of their income in taxes, but you're not entitled to argue that they not now paying much more than "middle class" earners.
Sunday, January 15, 2012
A Fable
Once upon a time there was a very large enterprise with a
long history of being the leader in its industry. In fact, it had a 25% share of
the world market – four times its closest competitor. It got to that position by
being the most efficient producer in the world. It was able to attract more
capital at lower costs because it delivered a much higher return on that
capital. It treated investors well. Then one day management started
to get lazy (as managements are wont to do). They worried less about
efficiency, market share, and investors and started worrying more about
rewarding themselves and being popular with the employees of the
business. They hired more and more workers and promised them lavish
retirement benefits. But instead of setting aside money in a pension fund, they
decided to simply pay those benefits from future cash flow, of which there
would surely be plenty. Over time, the employees became lazier as well
(as employees are wont to do). Instead of firing those that didn’t meet productivity
standards, management simply hired more and more of them. After all, it was
satisfying to come to work every day and read the employee newsletters about
how generous and wonderful you were. Besides, the investors were just
being greedy and interested only in the numbers. As equity investors
started moving capital toward start-up businesses with higher potential,
management formed an ESOP and simply borrowed more of its working capital.
After all, they had the strongest balance in the world. Borrowing was easy.
Employees wanted more benefits and fewer working hours. They had needs.
Management borrowed more and more and more until one day, the debt of the
enterprise equaled its entire annual production. Creditors started asking
questions. They downgraded the enterprise credit rating. Revenues sagged; benefit costs increased. Management borrowed more and more. They didn’t
pass an annual budget for years. Suddenly a large nosy group began to
question the wisdom of management. Maybe the business model is broken? Maybe we need to restructure? You know, the sort of turnaround thing
that private equity firms like Bain Capital do? Management was aghast. Private
equity firms are cruel and heartless. They fire people and take away your benefits
just to create higher returns for capital investors. We don’t need to be more
competitive. Things are just fine the way they are. We simply need more time
and more borrowing. Maybe we’ll give up one of the company picnics. Buy cheaper
paper for the copiers. Make our most productive people foot more of the pension
costs. That’s the ticket. Don’t panic. Everything will be alright. We know
what’s best for you. Have we ever lied to you?
And so, the enterprise reached a decision point. A
turnaround seemed like the necessary thing to keep the enterprise growing, but would surely be
painful for many. What if we had to change jobs or work more for what
we want? What if we had to live with the consequences of our own decisions? Although they didn’t trust management all that much, their plan sounded
a whole lot easier. No Pain. You Gain. Don’t Worry. Be Happy. You
deserve it! It's only fair. And so, they had to make a choice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)